Park Avenue Hotel – New York City – 1890 – Stunning & Ultra Rare – Hotel Silver Teapot with Zephyr Pattern - W.H. Earle & Sons, Proprietors for your consideration is a very rare 1890 stunning and absolutely beautiful winged designed – zephyr pattern 4” tall by 6 ½” wide (from the tip of the spout to the opposite side of the handle) 5/8 Pints (8 oz) silver plate teapot (with built in strainer) made for the Park Avenue Hotel that was located in New York City while under the ownership of W.H. Earle & Son.
Anything from the Park Avenue Hotel in New York is considered extremely rare. But, this is the first and only such piece thus far that I've seen specially marked for the hotel's owners in 1890: William H. Earle & Son Arthur.
If you collect historic New York items, vintage hotel silver, or historic Park Avenue items, you might want to consider this gem for your collection.
Historically, the Park Avenue dates back to the 1877 when an attractive seven story was constructed by New York merchant, A.T. Stewart, which bore the name "Stewart's Hotel". It was originally intended as a seven story hotel for only working women to stay at when and after arriving in New York City for employment.
The hotel was located directly on Park Avenue at 32nd & 33rd Streets. However, the hotel's operation only lasted a short time, as it opened in April of 1878 and closed a month later. However all was not lost, as the hotel's direction immediately changed from housing working women to that of a luxury hotel for those arriving in New York opening in June of that same year.
The new owners (which I still cannot determine who those were in 1878) opened it as the Park Avenue Hotel in June of 1878 with it becoming considered one of the city’s fine luxury hotels. By 1883, the hotel was under the lease operation of Henry Clair. By circa 1886, William H. Earle (whom this teapot is specially marked) had taken over the hotel.
The Park Avenue was advertised as being “one of the most massive structures in the world. It is constructed entirely of iron, steel, mortar, stone and brick. It would easily carry six more stories on ton of the present structures of seven stories. There are five iron fireproof stairways. The elevators are surrounded by brick walls. There is an unobstructed and open Interior court 100x120 feet. All of the floor girders are of steel, with brick or cement arch construction.(part one of an advertisement)
The building fronts on three streets Park avenue. Thirty-second and Thirty-third streets. lodges all around the front of the building extend four and one-half feet outside of windows. The halls throughout the building are ten feet wide, and each floor Is divided lnU five sections by doors. The fire alarms and appliances are absolutely up to date. There are 500 rooms in the hotel, which is conducted on the American and European plans by William II. Earle.-New York World.” (part two - information taken from a 19th Century hotel publication article on the hotel).
The hotel also offered baggage and shuttle service to and from the hotel from the then Grand Central Depot (it has yet not become the terminal) with no cost to the hotel’s guests. In 1899, the hotel's manager (not proprietor) was John M. Otter.
Wm. H. Earle & Son (the sone was Arthur Earle) were also the proprietors of Earle's Hotel from 1861 to 1872 (not the Park Avenue Hotel). It appears that after 1872, Ferdinand Earle became the sole proprietor of Earle's Hotel. Ferdinand was the brother to William, who was also General F.P. Earle.
In 1900, it appears that William retired from the operation of the Park Avenue Hotel (William passed in 1914). It was then that the hotel became under the ownership of Reed & Barnett; Frederick A. Reed. Sadly on February 22nd, 1902, at about 1:00 AM in the morning, fire broke out in the next door 71st Regiment Armory and quickly spread to the hotel. The ensuing fire caught fire claiming 20 lives (all guests arriving in New York to attend festivities to honor Prince Henry), injuring at least 50 others, and causing extensive damage to the 5th and 6th floors.
But, the Park Avenue was rebuilt and reopened. Under the new owners, the hotel was still a very popular place in New York. By the teens, the hotel had completed renovations, which included a “Wrap-around balcony dining area overlooking sunken palm garden dining area”. This dining room Veranda was absolutely magnificent and offered guest a wonderful experience and view. By 1917, the hotel was operating its “Oyster Bar”.
It was by 1923, the hotel had renovated and was only operating 383 rooms, but they were more spacious and offered finer appointments. In 1925, the hotel was under the direction of George C. Brown and rates were $2.25 and up per night. However by 1927, the hotel had closed and was subsequently demolished to make way for then modern development.
This tea pot is quite the attractive piece of vintage hotel silver. It has a stunning zephyr wing atop the handle and a very attractive finial atop the lid. It would have been used for ladies afternoon tea, hot coffee, hot chocolate, or even pre-prohibition cold and hot alcohol beverages.
It would have been used in connection with the Park Avenue Hotel china and glassware for actual table service in the hotel’s dining rooms, one of its restaurants, or for private room service. It is the heavyweight type steamship, restaurant, and railroad silverplate.
This piece is in excellent condition for its age. It has the usual light usage scratches some light silver plate loss, some minor dings, etc., that one would expect from being 130+ years old. The handle is slightly loose but still well attached to the pot and functional. The lid works well and base set even on a level surface. The inside is actually in nice condition with some light pitting, etc.
It was made by the Gorham Silver Co. in Providence, Rhode Island. It has the 1890 datemark, is silver soldered, marked 5/8 PINTS, has the catalog number of 06297, and is specially marked on the bottom “W.H. EARLE & SON”.
A wonderful addition to your home decorating / home furnishing, interior design, creamer / pitcher / coffee, or historic New York City collection.
Buyer to pay a standard shipping fee. No returns on any items; no exceptions with all sales being final.
Items can take up to three (3) days to ship (due to my schedule working at the animal rescue).
Please ask any questions and read the description before committing to purchase.
The proceeds of this sale go to fund the animal rescue that our family is operating.
Thank you for taking the time to view my listings.